.
News Alert
Fire Rips Through Setauket Home

B. Prestano's Bakery In Rocky Point Brings an Old Family Tradition

The B stands for Barbara, from the Prestano family of bakers, who bought the Rocky Point Bakery less than four years ago.

In 2008 Barbara Prestano and her husband Mike bought the Rocky Point Bakery, which now has the well-known name.

The Prestanos have been in the bakery business for generations, and the family owns Italian style bakeries all over Long Island.

"The old Rocky Point Bakery had been great in its time but right before we bought it there were a series of owners that changed every six months," he said. "They ruined its reputation."

Barbara and Mike have been hard at work to restore the bakery's distinction.

"My father taught my husband to bake," said Barbara Prestano. "I do all the cake decorating. I always knew I'd go into the family business...you're born into it."

The delicious smell of freshly baked bread permeates the store. Among the many choices offered are Italian Semolina, Chiabata, Whole Wheat French and Sicilian Chain. The Prestanos prepare specialty breads on the weekends.

Prestano's is known for its bread, and the recipe is a guarded family secret.

"It's my great grandfather's recipe," said Barbara Prestano. "It goes back generations. Our bread is an old fashioned crunchy crusted Sicilian style loaf."

The large oven that the bread is baked in is almost a half century old.

"It is an oil fired oven," her husband said. "The bottom of the oven is fire, not electric, and it is brick lined; you could never get this crust with an electric oven."

Gina Polizzo, a student at St. Joseph's College, mans the counter. 

"The Prestanos are warm, happy people. I love working here," she said. There's an old fashioned atmosphere. I do some of the sprinkling and dipping when the cookies are made."

Ursula Altieri, a customer, joked with Gina as she purchased a Cinnamon Twist.

"I think I'm in here every day," she said.

Glen Fisher of Sound Beach came in for rolls.

"I've got to come home with jelly doughnuts, they're huge, the kids love them," he said.

A Rocky Point tradition occurs after mass on Sunday at , when people cross the street and line up at the bakery's door.

"Everyone comes in for our famous bread, but the jelly doughnuts are a close second," Polizzo said. "We also have sugar-free apple turnovers and gluten free cookies."

Prestano's has all manner of things sweet and Italian, from hazelnut biscotti to fig cookies to cannolis, that will only be filled to order to ensure freshness and crispness.

antoinette July 13, 2011 at 10:39 PM
Ooh, I can smell the bakery as I read the above article. Now that the Prestano's are back in the store, I will definitely patronize them. A good product deserves to be advertised and eaten! Good luck to you.
Mary Gebbia July 14, 2011 at 10:18 AM
Delicious bakery goods and great people too!!
Mike Langer July 14, 2011 at 01:52 PM
This is Mike from Rocky Point Bakery-if you "bought" Rocky Point Bakery where is my check? There were 4 owners of Rocky Point Bakery between the years 1971-2008 with the last owners of Rocky Point Bakery between 2004-fire of 2008. Whatever it was after 2008 it was not The Rocky Point Bakery that the tradition was built on. Good Luck with your business but please get your facts straight
Mike Langer July 14, 2011 at 03:22 PM
I am sorry-in an effort to get the facts straight-the fire was Nov. 2007. The Rocky Point Bakery Era ended in Nov.2007. Thanks
Mike Langer July 14, 2011 at 03:40 PM
I'm sorry the fire was Nov 2007. So the last TRUE owners of Rocky Point Bakery were there until 2007.
kiddd35 July 14, 2011 at 04:38 PM
Very Family oriented... Unlike Tildas. For me they are the only bakery in Rocky Point! :)
Jenn Jorgensen July 14, 2011 at 07:35 PM
Why is there such a competitive nature between the two bake shops? It didn't seem that way when it was the Rocky Point Bakery. With all due respect, I also don't think it was fair of the Patch to post these two articles within days of each other. It encourages the competition. I'm sure both places have their good and bad days. And both places each offer their own special items.
Rich Arleo (Editor) July 14, 2011 at 09:39 PM
Thanks for the comment Jenn. We weren't trying to encourage competition, just sharing the story of both bakeries. People had asked for something on Prestano's, so that is what we did.
Mike Langer July 14, 2011 at 09:45 PM
Thank goodness ...Eddie at Tilda's was always more than helpful with Rocky Point Bakery- so there was never a competition.
Rich Arleo (Editor) July 15, 2011 at 01:37 PM
We appreciate the comments but please watch the language. All comments that violate our terms of use, found here -- http://millerplace-rockypoint.patch.com/terms -- will be deleted. Thanks
Kyle July 17, 2011 at 10:55 PM
I think the reason the competition was lesser when Rocky Point Bread owned the storefront that Prestano's now occupies, is because they focused their sales SOLELY on bread! Prestano's offers a wide variety of products including cakes, cookies, doughnuts, rolls, and pastries which Rocky Point Bread did not. This may be what caused the essence of competition between the two bakeries, as Tilda's and Prestano's now essentially sell the same goods! I find I like the atmosphere at Prestano's much better.. friendly help, delicious baked goods, and the bread is incomparable.
dar semmler April 07, 2012 at 02:52 AM
Earlier bakery ownership used decent ingredients. Later ones didn't and just "went cheap". Ugh! Bread was white cardboard taste. We hope new owners do much better!
dar semmler April 07, 2012 at 02:56 AM
What works in competition is QUALITY even of 1 product. Variety is nice but without quality ...it is a Big Zero.
robert October 25, 2012 at 04:20 PM
Is this the same Prestanos that used to be on E 235 St and White Plains Road in the Bronx!
Mike January 15, 2013 at 05:00 AM
My name is Michael Filippi my dad and I owned the bakery until 2005 that's the end of the real rocky point Italian bakery.
Rosemary Prestano Wilson June 15, 2013 at 08:37 PM
Barb, who is your father and granfather? My father eas Joe Prestano and grandparents were Rosalie and Dominick Prestano . Grandparents use to live in Patchauge.
Rosemary Prestano Wilson June 15, 2013 at 08:37 PM
Barb, who is your father and granfather? My father eas Joe Prestano and grandparents were Rosalie and Dominick Prestano . Grandparents use to live in Patchauge.

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something