.
Feedback

Brookhaven Extends Public Hearing on Bamboo Ban

Public hearing extended 10 days after opposition to new legislation.

At Tuesday's Broohaven Town Board meeting, the public hearing period for new legislation that would ban the planting of bamboo and regulate existing bamboo by extended by 10 days.

According to a report in the Times Beacon Record Newspapers, Councilwoman Kathy Walsh, R-Centereach, introduced the bill. If passed, bamboo planting by any resident or corporation in the Town of Brookhaven would be banned. Also, owners of pre-existing bamboo must "confine such species to prevent the encroachment, spread, invasion or intrusion" to any neighboring property.


The proposed law would set fines of $500 to $2,000 for violations. Those with bamboo would have 15 days to confine it. Second offenders face a fine between $1,000 and $3,000 with a maximum prison sentence of six months. A third violation would result in a Class B misdemeanor charge.

The first public hearing on the matter was held March 20. The extension to the public hearing was made due to opposition to the law and is designed to give residents time to write their concerns and send them to the board.

Click here to read the full report from the Times Beacon Record Newspapers.

Do you agree or disagree with the legislation? Share your thoughts in the comment section below and .

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Miller Place-Rocky Point Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Wantsummer123 April 27, 2012 at 02:22 pm
I'm not a fan of bamboo, but banning the damn thing is ridiculas. They should FINE only if it get into others property...same thing about ivy , Zoyzia and any other plant that grows out of control. Before anyone plant anything..they should make sure they border the property.
Had Enuf! April 27, 2012 at 02:47 pm
This cradle to grave mentality of the nanny state is killing us.
We need LESS government not more. Really.....with all the issues facing us from all levels of government, why is banning BAMBOO on the top of the list for Brookhaven? How long until Mimosa trees are banned due to their wispy seed pods? Or a mandatory removal of poison ivy on your property b/c it spreads to the neighbors. Another perfect example of "make work" by politicians, and another reason why these town board members should be part time and paid $1 per year for their service. Think that's crazy? Check out NH and TX state legislatures
gumby dammit April 27, 2012 at 03:04 pm
GTFOH... what is complete waste of time and money. Why can't they track down the person with 2 mattresses and a couch on the front lawn and fine them.
I don't have a stick of bamboo but 1 day I might want to... Personally I don't wanna stick around 4 what's next? Why don't we restrict my neighbors barbeque because the smoke bothers me. They truly is no end to the lunacy.
SashaK April 27, 2012 at 11:37 pm
Here's my opinion..each day we are losing our Freedoms at mock speed...Do we really need the government in our back yard? No. End of the story.
Matthew Lott April 28, 2012 at 02:04 pm
IF ANY of you naysayers had any experience with bamboo as a homeowner, you would know that ALL OF THIS is about your property values.
Bamboo is considered a "stigma", meaning "if" you sell your house you have to disclose the presence of bamboo on your property to prospective buyer at the time of sale, and if you don't the sale can be voided...meaning lots of lost money ALL AROUND. Also bamboo is so destructive a plant, on it's own and not "barriered" or enclosed properly, that it can destroy your cess pool, your foundation, the leeching of water near your foundation, and if you have a swimming pool, it's powerful to go right through the sides of the pool. All the WHINERS who are talking "nanny state" jibberish, have no personal experience with the destructive possibilities of bamboo to their property...as well as how irresponsible homeowners can be not caring about their actions to other members of the community. How about the "bamboo sellers" owning up to selling illegal, invasive plants to irresponsible homeowners ? NO that will never happen. This law is designed to make people responsible for their Actions, PERIOD, and punishing those homeowners who could care less about anyone, OTHER THAN THEMSELVES !
SashaK April 28, 2012 at 05:26 pm
@Matthew Lott...I am someone has grown up with bamboo that had been on the property. It was there when my parents got there. While you are indeed correct that the plant can be destructive/invasvie if left on it's own there is this little thing called "Personal Responsibility".If people are having problems with their neighbors regarding this then wouldn't speaking to them be the answer? Instead you want the government to take over..That's way worse than any bamboo. Those that actually may have bamboo are in the minority.We seriously do not need the government in our backyard instead of bamboo!
Had Enuf! April 28, 2012 at 05:40 pm
Bravo. SashaK. Bravo
Matthew Lott April 28, 2012 at 06:35 pm
You have to be kidding !
Matthew Lott April 28, 2012 at 06:47 pm
Try living next to a grove of NOT CONTROLLED bamboo, 37 square feet wide and three houses, or over 400 square feet long !
Matthew Lott April 29, 2012 at 11:11 am
You sound like a bamboo seller to us !
As for your socalled "Freedoms", don't look know but that other hand in your pocket is Mark Lesko and the Town Board...and they been there for some time now !
Matthew Lott April 29, 2012 at 11:12 am
Where have ALL of you socalled "Freedom Fighters" been for all these years in Brookhaven ?
Hiding behind your bamboo ?
SashaK April 29, 2012 at 12:56 pm
@Matthew..No..this Freedom Fighter..As God as my Wittness. does not have one single stick on my property.. I must say that nickname you gave me and a few others fit quite well ..Thank you ;=)
SashaK April 29, 2012 at 12:57 pm
@Had Enuf..Thank you for the support!! I can see being on these boards it gets pretty ruff out there so the support is greatly appreciated!
SashaK April 29, 2012 at 01:04 pm
@Matthew Lott. You think I'm a babmboo seller?..none of that makes sense at all. I'm the other hard working half of the family trying to raise our children in this crazy economy/world..Do you realize that you basically just agreed with me that I do NOT want the government any more in our backyards then in our pockets.....If people are found to have this bamboo then guess who the fine is paid too>Its about loss of Freedom and searching for revenue.
Matthew Lott May 1, 2012 at 04:13 pm
SashaK, Enjoy your bamboo, but minimizing it as harmless is being disingenuous.
Unfortunately, there are more people who could care LESS about keeping it under control than people like you. This is where a strict law like this one has to be passed, to protect us from those BOOBS who have no sense of personal responsibility.
muzta tugar May 2, 2012 at 02:19 pm
Matthew,
While it is not "harmless", it is WAY less capable of destruction than many tree roots. I have had bamboo next to my pool for 20 years. It's roots are very dependent upon greenery. To remove large areas of it, I merely trimmed it at ground level (reciprocating saw) and threw on some grass clippings and soil and.......thee end. It tries to sprout a few more times (just a kick to the 3 to 6 inch sprouts and they pop out) but then the root system suffers massive die-off. Try that with an oak or maple tree !
Matthew Lott May 2, 2012 at 02:25 pm
Oh yeah ?
Well that's your experience. But your background in the destructiveness of bamboo is sorely lacking. You are being disingenuous.
Jonnny D May 10, 2012 at 05:12 pm
What everyone who is not familiar with pllant species is this, there are 2 types of bamboo; " running" bamboo which sends up shoots at a distance and is highly invasive if not controlled, and "clumping" bamboo which stays strictly in a clump like hostas do. Any legislation must take this into consideration, and evaluate each home on a case by case basis.
Matthew Lott May 10, 2012 at 05:43 pm
It's all bad, eventually. Minimizing the destructiveness of bamboo is not telling the Truth.
Muzta Tugar May 13, 2012 at 04:08 pm
I dont think so......... I have removed it successfully in several places and therefore it seems I have MORE experience than you. Kinda looks like maybe the neighbors of yours are trying to block some sort of local pest ????
Muzta Tugar May 13, 2012 at 04:15 pm
Looks like MANY knowledgeable people disagree with you...... so we should rewrite the laws just for YOU ? Clumping bamboo can sit in a garden for decades without spreading, but you dismiss that as bad too. Why don't you just go to the zoo and see if you can rent a panda ?
Matthew Lott May 13, 2012 at 04:47 pm
Tell us "Muzta", do you sell bamboo ?
Muzta Tugar May 13, 2012 at 05:03 pm
Sorry Matt, bad guess. I have delt with controlling it extensively however and it is very doable. I do sympathize with you if your neighbor is unwilling to "contain " it as then there is not much YOU can do at the other end. However..... if it is cut down to the ground and covered it WILL die off in only 2 seasons and will be unable to produce large sprouts in only a month or so . What is your neighbors fixation with bamboo? Does HE sell it by any chance ?
Matthew Lott May 13, 2012 at 05:20 pm
Like most people they don't care to contain it, and this bill is suited for these types of people.
Muzta Tugar May 13, 2012 at 11:04 pm
Thats fine, as long as you dont have the town stepping in with their pseudoexperts telling people they must spend thousands of dollars to satisfy some arbitrary town idea thought up by the typical town no-knowledge politicians !
Helene May 19, 2012 at 01:07 pm
The purpose of government is to protect our freedom. My neighbor's bamboo in interfering with my use and enjoyment of my property for which I pay property tax. My neighbor knows that it is a problem and has not done anything about it. You sound somewhat ignorant SashaK. Maybe you should read more and blog less.
SashaK May 23, 2012 at 11:37 pm
@Helene.."You sound somewhat ignorant SashaK. Maybe you should read more and blog less."..My my..you feel it that necessary to tell me I am ignorant because my views are not the same as yours? That I should blog less? What makes me being passionate about my opinion ignorant? I am sorry you are having problems regarding your neighbor but don't you think your anger should be re-directed? Insulting me will not get us anywhere. My issue is all and ONLY about how much governent control do we really need.
David June 4, 2012 at 10:47 am
Absolutly agree with Matt. Oak and Maple trees can take years to grows roots that are as destructive as bamboo in a matter of months. Bamboo shoots are live spears underground, they basically will grow right through anything, cesspools, swimming pools, sprinkler lines, etc. Whereas tree roots tend to grow around.
David June 4, 2012 at 10:47 am
Because it is an invasive plant. Even if you cut it to the ground it grows right back. It will also grow through almost anything underground ie. cesspools, swimming pools, sprinkler lines, etc.
Matthew Lott June 4, 2012 at 12:02 pm
Muzta, This Law is designed to protect tax payers from those Irresponsible People who don't care about others and have No Respect for other people's property, and who don't exercise Common Sense about this issue.
It's not an "arbitrary" idea. Try selling your home in the vicinity of a bamboo forest and you will be surprised at just what your house value is. Unfortunately these "types" who don't care about others and who don't have respect for another person's property, are out there...but you wouldn't know from some of these posts. We are supposed to suspend our collective Intellect, and think everything is Pink Moons and Marshmallow Clouds ! It's a surprise but this legislation is very thoughtful..but if you are a Bamboo Lover you wouldn't think so.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Janene Gentile May 17, 2013 at 11:41 am
Yoga with Amy is wonderful!
Michelle Posner June 13, 2013 at 06:43 pm
I highly recommend Yoga with Amy!z